3 Generations of Willoughby
Willoughby Will When Nobody Will!!

The Willoughby team is committed to providing our clients with the highest quality insurance services combined with the lowest rates available in all of Western New York. Our outstanding insurance agents will work with you one on one to ensure that you get a solution that is tailored specifically to meet your needs.

Whether you are shopping for auto insurance, home, health, life or business insurance, our highly experienced team of insurance agents can help you find the right coverage at the lowest rate no matter what your needs are. No One Refused! No matter what you driving record or credit shows, Willoughby Will When Nobody Will!!

Our ultimate goal is to create lasting relationships with each of our clients so that we may continue providing excellent service for many years to come. Unlike many of the larger nationwide insurance companies that are out there, all of your information will be kept secure and private.

The Willoughby name is trusted throughout the community. We have been in business for over 60 years! Walter Willoughby started the Willoughby Insurance agency in 1952 out of his house at 257 Minnesota Ave right here in Buffalo. His only son Jeff took over in the 80's and grew the business into what it is today! Jeff's son Craig took control back in 2002 and has been running the business ever since!

To speak directly with an experienced insurance professional, simply give us a call anytime or feel free to utilize any of the interactive tools offered throughout the site. We look forward to working with you.

Willoughby Insurance

yelp googleplaces

1523 Main St.
Buffalo, NY 14209

Office: (716) 885-8100
Fax: (716) 882-7541
Email: craig@willoughbyinsurance.com


Willoughby Insurance

yelp googleplaces

1923 Seneca St
Buffalo, NY 14210

Office: (716) 827-0500
Fax: (716) 827-0108
Email: diana@willoughbyinsurance.com

145 resize

Willoughby Insurance


2244 Pine Ave
Niagara Falls, NY 14301

Office: (716) 285-5088
Fax: (716) 285-5179
Email: wendy@willoughbyinsurance.com